
Can you really compete with Girl Scouts?
As of now, not really. But one day I will. And I'll win.
A week ago (two weeks ago? I can't keep track of time!), I tried my hand at some homemade thin mints in our crowded kitchen. Look at that! People just don't clean up in communal kitchens and it's so annoying. Okay, so maybe some of that stuff is mine (the blue bowl, measuring cups, chocolate chips, and tin foil, but otherwise the dirty dishes in the background are NOT mine!) but it was so crowded in there. Anyways.
I had time to bake and this cookie recipe took a lot of time. You need to make the dough, roll them into logs and freeze them for an hour or so, and then slice and bake. Pretty simple, but time consuming. I started baking with Danielle and we embarked on the task together.

The batter is interesting. There's no egg and it's very, very dry, but you just have to keep mixing it until it becomes dough. Towards the end, I just ended up sticking my hands in the chocolate mix and kneading it by hand. Worked just as well but it definitely didn't feel like cookie dough. But it tasted alright! Chocolate and peppermint extract...can't go wrong. After the dough was finished, I rolled them into the logs and, well, let's just say Danielle and I couldn't help but laugh.
Seriously. I mean, come on. It's funny looking! You know what we were thinking.

Actually, I could have made them thinner, definitely, since Thin Mints are, well, thin. And they're not soft cookies so biting into a thick homemade thin mint might hurt. After freezing them for an hour, I sliced them and placed them on baking sheets and waited. They're funny little biscuit-cookies. They don't expand and take shape like normal cookies. These guys, they just get a little harder, but not much. After the baking time, we took them out of the oven and let them cool. they looked like little hockey pucks, but luckily were much softer than one.

Of course, Thin Mints have a chocolate coating on top. Before we began dipping the biscuit-cookies in melted chocolate and butter, Danielle and I tried a plain one. Not bad. Although next time, maybe I'd up the peppermint extract and chocolate because I think some of the peppermint was lost in the baking process. After the cookies were cooled, we began dipping, which was probably the most fun. Who doesn't like melted chocolate? We set them on tin foil and carried them to the freezer to set (that required so much teamwork it was crazy). And that was my first foray into thin mints.
You might be wondering how the held up? Well...the feedback I got was basically all the same: good, strange, hard cookies but ultimately, like a thin mint. As for me, I'm not too sure. All that effort for an alright cookie? One day I'll try 'em again and slice the cookies thinner, but they did taste good, especially with a generous chocolate coating over them. People did eat them (although not as much as muffins or other cookies I've baked), so I'm happy. A good experiment and challenge overall.
The recipe was found
here, and her thin mints look so much more authentic than mine. Definitely the slicing.
Oh, and look! It's almost Thanksgiving! Can't wait to get home and see friends and family and bake in a real kitchen.

<3